While a lot of people are oohing and aahing over Starship Flight 15 and talking about a “New Age of Space Exploration,” I am still not sold on Starship. And while some people will probably just go, “You’re just an Elon hater,” and stop reading here, I – after pointing out there are many legitimate reasons to hate Elon – figured I should give some solid reasons for my concerns. And with Flight 15, there were three things that concerned me. Well, two and half.
My first “concern”
is more of a disappointment in that they didn’t catch the booster. The explanation I saw was that they ran low
on fuel, which they should be able to fix by staging a second or two
earlier. If that is all it is, then it
is an easy fix. And it is good to see
how it was able to divert when it realized things weren’t right for a
catch. The reason this is a “concern,” is
that they have caught boosters before, but not for six or seven flights. Now I understand this is still a test vehicle
and it’s likely they’ve tried some unoptimal reentries to see how far they can
push the booster, which is great, but they also need to test catching the damn
thing. Because showing you can catch a
booster is great, but the real trick is showing that you can do it reliably
over and over and over again. Now if,
for whatever reason, they fail to catch the booster on Flight 16, this
“disappointing concern” will become a legitimate concern and we should start
asking if there is some larger issue at play.
My next real
concern is about the engine going out during the boostback. I label this a concern because I’m pretty
sure there have been engine issues on the majority of the flights. Possibly even on all of them, although I
don’t really care to go back and check. The
Starship we were sold, is one that launches, the booster comes back to the pad,
gets flushed out and then refueled and launches again, possibly even the same
day. And I imagine that every five or
ten flights the booster would be taken to a hanger and given a full inspection
to make sure everything is still working.
But if engines keep going out, then the booster would be caught, and
then taken to a hanger where the engine would be pulled out and replaced before
going back to the launch tower. Instead
of a booster that could possibly fly ten times a week, we might get boosters
that can only fly two or three times a week.
Still impressive, but not what we were sold.
My final concern
is with the Starship itself, which while it was caught, still lost at least one
heatshield tile. This is a similar
concern as the engine issues. We were
sold on a ship that could launch, transfer fuel to an orbital depot, land get
fueled up again and fly, possibly even that day. But if after every mission it has to go back
to the hanger to get tiles replaced, it will really cut into the high launch
cadence this rocket is supposed to deliver.
Don’t get me
wrong, I do find the Starship an engineering marvel, and everyone who built it
and flies it should be congratulated. But
the reason I’m still not sold on it is the worry that they are pushing it
beyond its capabilities. For the longest
time I’ve felt that if they had started with an expendable second stage, they would
have had multiple booster recoveries and so many more reentry tests that they
would probably have like 90% of the data they have now, with the bonus of
having launched hundreds of satellites. But
they had to set a goal so far ahead that, it just might be out of reach.
My other worrying
concern about Starship is the role it will play in returning to the moon. Now, I’m a big fan of returning to the moon –
see my collection of essays, The Moon Before Mars: Why returning to the moon makes more sense than rushing off to Mars – but I am not a fan of the current
plans on returning to the moon. My
feeling is if, ten years ago, we had decided on a plan that relied solely on
Falcon 9 size rockets, we’d probably be on the moon now. But instead, we opted for these ginormous
rockets that, surprise surprise, ended up years behind schedule. Now some will say that using smaller rockets
would make things more complex because you’d have to launch pieces on a bunch
of them, then dock them in orbit, and then send it all to the moon. Which is true. But with these ginormous rockets, we have to
launch a bunch of them to refuel a depot in orbit to refuel the craft that then
goes to the moon. And my worry is that
some day SpaceX might wonder why they should launch a dozen Starships to carry
fuel up to go to the moon, when they could make so much more money using those
dozen Starships to launch their AI data center satellites. And some will say I’m not taking into account
how things will change when we’re launching thousands of Starships each
year. But they can only launch thousands
of Starships each year if they get the engine and heat tile issues
resolved.
No comments:
Post a Comment